In a small town in East Tennessee, a group of middle school cheerleaders filmed a 45-second TikTok video. What happened next wasn’t a timeout or a phone call home – it was handcuffs and criminal charges.
Sixteen girls at South Greene Middle School, some as young as 11, were charged with disorderly conduct after pretending to play dead in a classroom as part of a TikTok skit in which the kids play-acted as a shooter and victims.
The local sheriff said they had to be “held accountable through the court system.”
That’s right. Criminal court.
Fear Over Facts
This isn’t the only time Tennessee kids have been treated like criminals for bad jokes or misunderstandings.
-
A 13-year-old autistic boy was arrested for telling a teacher not to look in his backpack because it might “blow up”.
-
A 10-year-old was expelled for pointing his fingers like a gun on the playground.
-
A 12-year-old in Nashville was charged for resharing someone else’s screenshot of a threatening message.
Zero Tolerance, Zero Sense
A 16-year-old honors student used an AI app to create a parody video of a friend jokingly making threats. It was clearly fake, and his own dad made him delete it as soon as he found out about it.
Still, the student was expelled for a year and charged with a felony.
His dad, a teacher, later found a similar case in Pennsylvania where the court ruled against the school. Still, the Tennessee school wouldn’t back down. The student lost friends, his girlfriend, and his spot in school.
His story isn’t rare anymore. As fear of school shootings grows and social media spreads fast, many schools and police seem to be skipping a crucial step: thinking before reacting.
The Real Problem Isn’t the Kids
Back in Greene County, even the assistant cheer coach got caught in the fallout. She lost her job for not stopping the girls from filming.
The video had already been deleted by the time she even knew it was posted.
Everyone involved learned a lesson. But did it really need to be taught with a criminal charge and a court date?
These girls weren’t making threats. They were playing around. No one was actually hurt. No one was ever in danger.
Conclusion: Bring Back Common Sense
School safety matters – period. No one is saying it doesn’t. But we have to be able to tell the difference between real threats and childish behavior.
Putting these girls through the legal system for a distasteful joke hurts their future, and could likely leave some pretty heavy damage on the girls’ psyche.
What happened in Tennessee wasn’t law and order. It was a lazy, fear-driven, knee-jerk reaction.
Conservatives believe in personal responsibility, but we also believe in reasonable consequences.
Kids aren’t terrorists for making dumb jokes. They’re kids.
This article was written with the assistance of AI. Please verify information and consult additional sources as needed.
