Supreme Court to Weigh Chattah’s Fight to Lead Nevada Prosecutors

Posted By


 

The battle over Nevada’s top federal prosecutor could change how presidents fill key jobs when the Senate refuses to act.

Can Sigal Chattah keep running Nevada’s U.S. Attorney’s Office without ever getting a Senate vote? The U.S. Supreme Court may soon decide.

The justices are set to discuss the Justice Department’s appeal at their private conference on Friday, Dec. 4. That is when they vote on which cases to take. A similar fight over a U.S. attorney in New York is on the same list.

If four justices agree, the case goes forward. If not, a lower court ruling against Chattah stands.

How We Got Here

Chattah is a well-known Nevada Republcian. She led legal fights for churches during the COVID shutdowns, served as the state’s GOP National Committeewoman and ran for attorney general in 2022.

After President Trump took office, then-Attorney General Pam Bondi named her interim U.S. attorney starting April 1, 2025. That job comes with a 120-day limit.

To stay longer, she needed Senate confirmation. That was never going to happen.

Nevada’s two Democratic senators, Jacky Rosen and Catherine Cortez Masto, opposed her. Rosen pledged not to return a “blue slip,” a Senate tradition that lets home-state senators block nominees.

So the administration tried another route.

Just before her term ran out, Chattah resigned. Bondi then named her “first assistant,” the office’s No. 2 job.

Under a 1998 law called the Federal Vacancies Reform Act, the first assistant can step up as acting head when the top job is empty. In her resignation letter, Chattah wrote that she “look[ed] forward to continuing to lead the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Nevada.”

What the Courts Said

Defendants in several federal criminal cases challenged that move. In September 2025, U.S. District Judge David Campbell disqualified Chattah from their cases, writing that the process the Justice Department used “was never intended by Congress.”

He did not throw out the indictments.

In August, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit agreed unanimously. The court said you cannot become acting U.S. attorney by being named first assistant after the job is already vacant.

The ruling has been paused while the Supreme Court decides, so Chattah remains in the office for now.

Nevada is not alone. Courts have also ruled against Trump picks in New Jersey, New York, Virginia and California.

The Administration’s Case

The Justice Department says the lower courts got the law wrong. In its petition, Solicitor General D. John Sauer called the first-assistant approach “a critical tool that the Executive Branch has used without meaningful objection for 25 years.”

He noted that both Republican and Democratic administrations have used it.

The administration also warned that the Ninth Circuit ruling affects U.S. attorneys’ offices across the West that handle more than 8,000 cases a year. And it pointed out that federal appeals courts disagree on how the law works, which is one of the main reasons the Supreme Court takes a case.

The Other Side

Critics say the administration found a loophole to dodge the Senate.

The defendants argue that confirming U.S. attorneys is the Senate’s job, not something the attorney general can work around. More than 100 former judges from both parties signed a 2025 letter urging that Chattah not be appointed permanently.

The White House has nominated Las Vegas attorney George Kelesis for the permanent job. His nomination is still pending.

What Comes Next

After the Dec. 4 conference, the justices could take the case, turn it down or hold it for later. If they take it, arguments would likely come next year. A decision could set the rules for acting officials across the whole federal government.

Whatever you think of Chattah, Nevada deserves a U.S. attorney whose authority is not in doubt.

The opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Nevada News & Views. This article was written with the assistance of AI.