Fire Safety or Water Waste? County Weighs Desert Water Rule Change Sparked by Red Rock Pond

Posted By


 

Clark County commissioners will decide Wednesday whether to change desert water rules for a luxury development near Red Rock.

A luxury housing project near Red Rock Canyon wants to build a big pond. The developers say it would help fight wildfires. Their neighbors in Blue Diamond can’t even get new water hookups.

On Wednesday, November 18, the Clark County Commission will take up application TA-26-0567. It would change the county’s development code. Right now, the county limits “nonessential” water features in the desert. The change would carve out an exception for certain private ponds used for fire suppression.

County planning staff recommends denial. The Planning Commission disagreed and voted 6–1 to send it forward.

What’s Being Proposed

The Reserve at Red Rock sits on about 65 acres at the old Bonnie Springs Ranch. It used to be a tourist stop. Now it is being turned into 16 luxury estates. Some lots have been marketed for more than $9 million, according to The Nevada Independent.

The developers want to build what they call a “dip pond.” Fire helicopters and crews could pull water from it during a wildfire. It would hold about 780,000 gallons. That’s a bit more than an Olympic swimming pool holds.

The developers say the water would come from the ranch’s own private water rights, about 114 acre-feet a year. They say none of it would come from the Colorado River, which supplies most of the Las Vegas Valley.

The Nevada Division of Forestry supports having access to the pond. Fire officials told the Planning Commission it could speed up the first response to a blaze near Red Rock. The area has burned before, including the 2013 Carpenter 1 Fire.

Why It Matters

Conservatives believe in property rights. If you own water rights, you should be able to use them within the law. That’s a fair point in the developers’ favor.

But conservatives also believe rules should apply to everyone the same way. Government shouldn’t write special exceptions for well-connected people.

That’s the problem here. Commissioners aren’t just approving one pond. They’re being asked to rewrite the county code. County staff warned the language is too loose. It doesn’t set clear limits on size, design, or other uses.

And there may be other uses.

The developers’ attorney, Bob Gronauer, told planning commissioners the water could be used for irrigation when it isn’t needed for fires. A firefighting pond that also waters a luxury landscape is a different thing.

There’s also a question about whose idea this was.

Gronauer described the pond as built at the request of the Forestry Division. But forestry officials told The Indy the developers approached them about a partnership.

The Neighbors Next Door

Just down the road, Blue Diamond relies on two shallow wells. The water table there dropped about 20 feet between 2020 and 2023. A moratorium on new water connections began in 2020. It’s still in place.

Think of it this way. Your neighbor can’t add a bathroom because the town well is low. Meanwhile, the gated community up the road gets permission for a pond.

The developers say the pond won’t touch Blue Diamond’s water system. Critics like Save Red Rock say the springs and groundwater in the area are all connected. No one has done a study yet to prove it either way.

Blue Diamond resident Pauline Van Betten told the Planning Commission the change is:

“Irresponsible for the county and it’s irresponsible for Red Rock.”

Two town advisory boards, Bunkerville and Moapa, also voted 4–0 against it. Those votes are only advisory. But they show concern reaches beyond Red Rock, since the rule would apply countywide.

What Happens Next

Commissioners could approve the change as written, deny it, or ask for a narrower rule with clearer limits. Even if it passes, the developers would still need other permits before building.

Whatever they decide, the vote will shape how Clark County handles requests like this in the future. Residents who want a say can contact their county commissioner before Wednesday or speak during public comment at the meeting.

The opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Nevada News & Views. This article was written with the assistance of AI.