I Didn’t Move to Nevada to Watch It Become the Place I Left.
I moved to Las Vegas from Washington state, and I’ll be honest about why: taxes. Call me a tax refugee. There are more of us arriving every month.
Here’s the funny thing nobody told me. I didn’t escape Washington’s tax system. I found it again — same architecture, smaller appetite. For now.
Start with what’s identical.
Neither state has an income tax. Nevada wrote the ban into its constitution; Washington’s courts and voters have kept one out for 90 years. Neither state taxes corporate profits.
\Instead, both tax gross receipts — money coming in the door, profit or no profit. Washington calls it the business and occupation tax. Nevada calls it the commerce tax. Different name, same animal.
Both tax payroll, too.
Nevada’s modified business tax takes 1.17 percent of wages above $50,000 a quarter. Washington takes its cut in slices — workers’ comp, unemployment insurance, paid family and medical leave, the WA “cares” tax — but it’s the same idea: tax the job before the worker ever sees a paycheck.
And both bury you in hidden levies.
Washington’s Department of Revenue counts more than 50 taxes and fees in its own Tax Reference Manual. Nevada’s catalogue is shorter, but it’s the same genre: fuel taxes, a real property transfer tax, a governmental services tax on your car, a $1 tire fee, cannabis and liquor excises, a live entertainment tax.
The taxes you can’t see — the ones folded into prices and experienced as inflation instead of a bill — are the same here as there.
So why does Nevada feel so much lighter?
Three reasons, and not one of them is the design of the tax code.
First, thresholds. Washington’s B&O tax hits every business from the first dollar — the corner grocer, the solo practitioner, everybody. Nevada’s commerce tax doesn’t touch revenue under $4 million, so most small businesses never even file.
Second, tourists. Gaming taxes, room taxes of more than 13 percent on the Strip, entertainment taxes — 40 million visitors a year pay a big share of Nevada’s cost of government. Washington has nobody to export its taxes to, so Washingtonians pay them all.
Third, and most important: Nevada’s government is simply smaller. Its general fund runs about $5 billion a year. Washington’s operating budget has doubled in a decade, to $80 billion a biennium, or $40 billion a year.
Notice what those three reasons have in common: None of them is a law of nature. Each one is a choice, renewed or abandoned by whoever holds the governorship and the Legislature.
And that’s my caution, from a man who has already watched this movie.
Washington’s B&O tax was born in 1933 as a temporary Depression-era measure. Temporary. It is now the pillar of an $80 billion budget.
Nevada’s commerce tax, meanwhile, was created in 2015 and signed by a Republican governor over the objections of his own party’s base.
Fiscal appetite is not a Democratic disease or a Republican one. It’s a government disease. The party in control matters only to the extent it has — or lacks — the discipline to say no.
The machinery of a Washington-style tax state is already installed in Nevada. The gross receipts tax exists; its threshold can be lowered and its rates raised, one modest adjustment at a time. The payroll tax exists. The excises exist.
All that stands between Nevada and Washington’s cost of living is the spending restraint of the people in Carson City, and restraint is the first casualty of a budget shortfall, a sympathetic cause or a governor with a legacy project.
I like it here. I intend to stay. But I didn’t move to Nevada to watch it become the place I left. The welcome mat for tax refugees stays out only as long as Nevada remembers why we came.
The opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Nevada News & Views. Digital technology may have been used in the research, writing, or production of this article. Please verify information and consult additional sources as needed.