Three Primaries, Three Slash-and-Burn Campaigns, One Common Thread
There’s a new loyalty test in Northern Nevada.
If you’re a Republican who won’t vote for David Flippo, some folks say you’re a traitor. You’re dishonorable. You’re helping the Democrats.
The argument goes like this: The primary’s over. GOP voters picked their nominee. Now every good Republican must fall in line. No questions asked.
But there’s a problem.
The people demanding loyalty now haven’t shown much of it to fellow Republicans themselves.
So if we apply the same loyalty standard to Team Flippo, how have they treated fellow Republicans?
McShane’s Latest Target
The latest was a shot by Flippo’s campaign consultant, Rory McShane, against Bob Seale.
This week, Seale filed an FEC complaint against the Flippo campaign. According to The Washington Post, the complaint raised questions about the accuracy of Flippo’s campaign finance reports.
That includes reporting that a person listed as a major donor said they had not contributed.
In an X post today, McShane trashed Seale for having supported a Democrat in the past.
What he failed to mention, naturally, is that the Democrat in question, Zach Conine, was running against one of Rory’s clients, Michele Fiore, for state treasurer in 2022.
Rory doesn’t take it very well when somebody starts messing with his gravy train.
But beyond that 2022 race, here’s what else Rory left out about Seale.
Who Bob Seale Really Is
Seale is a former Republican Nevada state treasurer, state party chairman and state assemblyman. His career in Republican politics goes back more than 40 years.
His professional background is in accounting and money management.
So if he sees something fishy in Flippo’s campaign finance reports, well, there’s probably something fishy in Flippo’s campaign finance reports.
Seale served as state treasurer from 1991 to 1999. He was president of the National Association of State Treasurers in 1995.
In 1999, he received the Jesse Unruh Award for Outstanding Treasurer of the Year.
He was the elected Nevada Republican Party chairman from 2000 to 2003.
Before that, he served as treasurer of the Washoe County Republican Party from 1982 to 1986, and of the state Republican Party from 1986 to 1989.
Seale also served one term in the Nevada Assembly, from November 2004 to November 2006. He represented Clark County’s Assembly District 21 as a Republican.
Now… tell us again about Flippo’s Nevada Republican background and service, Rory.
Oh, that’s right. He has none.
And here’s something else Rory probably doesn’t even know… or left out if he did.
During his first campaign for state treasurer, Seale survived a Sept. 3, 1990, plane crash near Fallon that killed his wife, Judy.
The passengers included lieutenant governor candidate Sue Wagner, campaign aide Stephanie Tyler and Seale’s campaign manager, Brian Krolicki.
Seale and Wagner were seriously injured.
But, yeah, he supported a better-qualified Democrat over Rory’s candidate in 2022… so let’s trash him as a Republican traitor, right?
How disgusting.
All Aboard the “Fraud Freight Train”!
Rep. Mark Amodei holds the seat Flippo wants. And here’s what he said on Nevada Newsmakers about Flippo’s primary campaign against James Settelmeyer:
“You ran an absolutely scurrilous campaign against a guy who’s one of the nicest guys around. The voters are never wrong, but guess what? Mark Amodei’s not endorsing him.”
And he didn’t stop there.
In a recent interview with The Wall Street Journal, Amodei explained why he won’t get on board:
“I’m proud of the fact that I’m a Republican, but that doesn’t mean that I’m going to step in front of basically a fraud freight train and go, ‘Well, it’s a Republican freight train, so it isn’t going to hurt when it splatters me all over the tracks.’”
That’s a sitting Republican congressman calling his own party’s nominee a “fraud freight train.”
Enter Jim Gibbons
So this week, Rory trotted out former Nevada Gov. Jim Gibbons, one of Flippo’s state chairs, to trash Amodei.
In typical Flippo-McShane style, Gibbons torched fellow Republican Amodei for not falling in line and climbing aboard that freight train.
In an op-ed published by the Reno Gazette-Journal, Gibbons – a man with more than a few skeletons of his own in the closet – accused Amodei of throwing a “tantrum” and being “childish” and “selfish.”
But he went well beyond that.
Gibbons also argued that Amodei, a military veteran himself, had violated his “oath to support and defend the Constitution of the United States.”
He went on to say that oath “does not expire when your friend loses. It does not expire when your feelings are hurt.”
And he concluded that Amodei “has decided that his personal grudge is more important than his party, more important than this district and more important than the Constitution he swore to defend.”
WTF?
Maybe I missed something in that oath, so I looked it up to be sure.
Amodei took this oath as an Army officer. He took it again as a member of Congress. Here it is:
“I, (name), do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office on which I am about to enter. So help me God.”
Where does it say Amodei swore an oath to David Flippo or the Nevada Republican Party?
If it’s there, I do solemnly swear I can’t find it.
Shooting the Messenger
It’s not just Republicans who get the smear treatment. Anyone who asks questions does.
Brittany Sheehan, our senior political writer at Nevada News & Views, has spent months digging into Flippo’s residence, finances and military record.
McShane and Flippo’s then-campaign manager, Woodrow “Woody” Johnston, went after her on X.
“I hope you’re getting paid well for this Brittany,” McShane wrote on April 20.
It was a false insinuation that she was on Settelmeyer’s payroll.
The next day, he went further.
“If you’re campaign comms great, sling all [the] mud you want,” he wrote.
“Sling all [the] mud you want.”
That’s how McShane describes the campaign business. Keep it in mind.
In April, Brittany wrote that Flippo was “blurring the lines of stolen valor.”
Johnston called that “a absolutely meritless and disgusting accusation.”
But then the Washington Post recently reported that Flippo had repeatedly claimed a Bronze Star “for valor” when, in fact, he’d received a standard Bronze Star, not one for valor.
Flippo apologized and blamed his staff.
And when it came to the two valor pins on his cap? Unbelievably, he blamed his grandkids!
“Meritless and disgusting”?
Turns out Brittany was right.
The Settelmeyer Smears
To understand why so many Republicans are fed up with Flippo and McShane, you have to rewind to the spring.
In February, Amodei announced he wouldn’t run again. Flippo quit his race in the 4th Congressional District, jumped to CD2 and moved his family to Reno.
Kinda like the Beverly Hillbillies.
His main opponent was former state Senate Republican Leader James Settelmeyer.
Settelmeyer is a fourth-generation rancher from Minden. Amodei and Gov. Joe Lombardo both endorsed him.
What followed was butt-ugly. Like… Rosie O’Donnell butt-ugly.
Twisting the Record
The Nevada Independent wrote that Flippo’s team had “zero qualms about attacking Settelmeyer’s record in ways that distorted his views.”
Two examples.
Settelmeyer voted for driver authorization cards. Applicants had to pass tests, prove their identity and buy insurance.
Flippo’s side falsely called it a vote for “driver licenses” for illegal immigrants.
Settelmeyer also voted for a bill to stock school bathrooms with menstrual products. Every Republican state senator voted for it.
The bill didn’t say anything whatsoever about boys’ bathrooms. But Flippo’s attack dogs turned it into “tampons in boys’ bathrooms.”
A conservative blog called 360 News Las Vegas, under the byline “Andrew Smith,” ran both attacks. Remember that site. It comes up again.
Settelmeyer put it bluntly.
“His campaign, from the get-go, five minutes after I filed, was about negative campaigning against me.”
Then it got personal.
The Sealed Court Records
A 2005 domestic violence charge against Settelmeyer surfaced on a little-known blog called The Populist Sentinel. Here’s what the blog didn’t make clear.
Settelmeyer was found not guilty. Douglas County District Attorney Mark Jackson remembers the case. “The judge used the word ‘exonerated,’” he said.
The records had been sealed since 2005. So how did they get out?
Settelmeyer’s campaign laid out a theory.
It said the records went from a private individual to the spouse of a Douglas County commissioner.
From there, it said, they went to a relative working at the political firm running Flippo’s campaign. That’s McShane’s firm, now called RMC.
Here are the documented facts.
Amy Tarkanian is married to Douglas County Commissioner Danny Tarkanian. She’s a friend of Settelmeyer’s ex-wife. Her relative, Alex Tarkanian, works at RMC.
Alex Tarkanian told the Indy he never saw the documents. Amy Tarkanian didn’t respond to the Indy. But she did comment on a Nevada GOP post supporting Flippo.
“I moved [Settelmeyer’s] ex wife out of the house,” she wrote. “I choose wisely.”
And here’s a fun fact.
In 2022, Amy Tarkanian, a former Nevada GOP chairwoman, was listed right alongside Bob Seale as a Republican backing Democrat Zach Conine for treasurer.
Funny how McShane hasn’t trashed her for it. I wonder why?
“Who Framed Roger Rabbit?”
An unaffiliated source told the Indy that McShane had the court records before they were published.
McShane didn’t directly answer that. He said he didn’t send them to the blog.
“It’s easy for our opponent to make allegations without any evidence,” McShane said, clearly speaking from experience.
Then he added: “I have evidence that Mr. Settelmeyer’s consultant was the one who framed Roger Rabbit.”
The Douglas County DA confirmed his office was looking into whether anyone accessed the sealed records illegally.
A pro-Flippo super PAC then cited the blog story in a video texted to voters.
The Young Republicans Brouhaha
Even the Young Republicans got dragged in.
The Washoe County Young Republicans endorsed Settelmeyer.
The state YR group, chaired by Johnston, then denied the Washoe chapter’s charter.
Johnston told the Indy the chapter had violated the bylaws. He called a Washoe member’s account false and defamatory.
Washoe members, rightfully so, said Johnston had a conflict of interest because he worked for Flippo.
After the primary, Amodei summed it all up.
He said he’d just watched a candidate “who had every right to be in the race get pulled, spindled and mutilated.”
But Settelmeyer wasn’t Team Flippo’s first target of 2026.
Cody Whipple and the Secret Tape
Before Amodei retired, Flippo was running in the 4th Congressional District.
His GOP primary opponent there was Cody Whipple, a fourth-generation Nevadan and Lincoln County rancher.
On Feb. 14, 360 News Las Vegas, the same site that later ran the Settelmeyer attack lines, posted a video of Whipple.
The site is run by Rob Lauer, a disreputable Las Vegas political gadfly.
In the video, Whipple seemingly trashes ex-cops and ex-military in politics.
He also appeared to take shots at Gov. Lombardo and Nevada GOP Chairman Michael McDonald, whose state party hired McShane’s firm after the 2020 election.
Whipple cried foul. He told me at the time that “they clipped three to four different conversations together to create the single audio piece.”
Three days later, 360 News posted what it called the full, unedited recording. The site said it was one continuous conversation at a Lazy Dog restaurant in Las Vegas.
And that’s when it got even more interesting.
The Man Across the Table
360 News identified the man on the other side of the table. His name is Joseph Michael.
The site described him as Deputy Grassroots Director for the Nevada Young Republicans.
According to 360 News, Michael was walking Whipple through a Young Republicans candidate questionnaire and suggested he could help Whipple get the YR endorsement.
Whipple didn’t get it. The Young Republicans endorsed Flippo.
And who runs the Nevada Young Republicans?
Woody Johnston, who was also running Flippo’s campaign at the time. And the YR website lists Michael as its Las Vegas chapter political director.
Think about that for a second.
The man who secretly recorded Flippo’s Republican opponent worked under the man running Flippo’s campaign.
And he did it while dangling an endorsement from the group that man chairs.
And that group then endorsed Flippo. Talk about a tangled web!
Does any of this prove Johnston or Flippo ordered the recording? No. And I’m not saying it does.
But it’s one heck of a coincidence. If you believe in coincidences.
And that wasn’t the only hit.
The Residency Attack
The Nye County Republican Party had endorsed Flippo. And it accused Whipple of falsifying his voter registration over his home address.
It then called on him to drop out, saying his candidacy “exposes the Republican Party to credible accusations of voter fraud.”
Whipple’s response?
“That was basically an attack by David Flippo and his team, nothing more.”
For the record, Johnston was photographed at the Nye County GOP’s 2026 Lincoln Day Dinner. Standing next to him were Nye GOP Chairman Leo Blundo and David Flippo.
Blundo’s got a closet full of skeletons of his own.
In 2023, the Nevada Commission on Ethics fined him $4,500 and publicly reprimanded him.
He hadn’t properly disclosed his financial interest before voting on Nye County’s pandemic relief program. His restaurant then collected the full $50,000.
And in March, a federal grand jury indicted him on wire fraud and money laundering charges. Prosecutors allege he obtained more than $500,000 in COVID relief money using inflated numbers.
Blundo has pleaded not guilty. He calls the case a “political witch hunt.”
Talk about birds of a feather flocking together.
Anyway, Whipple also told the Indy about a baseball game he attended with Flippo. Whipple said Flippo spent the game trying to convince him to run in a different district.
As it turned out, Flippo’s the one who hopped on his magic carpetbag and skedaddled north.
And here’s the kicker.
That tape didn’t stay in the primary. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee is now using it against Whipple in his CD4 race against Democrat Rep. Steven Horsford.
So much for party unity.
But Whipple and Settelmeyer still weren’t the first to run into the Flippo Smear Machine.
The John Lee “Sexual Predator” Website
In 2024, Flippo ran in the Republican primary for the 4th Congressional District.
His main opponent was the exceptionally successful former North Las Vegas Mayor John Lee, who had endorsements from Donald Trump and Gov. Lombardo.
Days before the primary, an anonymous attack website popped up.
It called Lee a “sexual predator” based on a 25-minute recording of a man arranging a sexual meetup with a woman and her 13-year-old daughter.
Lee’s campaign said the voice “is clearly not of John Lee.” It said the recording was fabricated or made with deepfake AI.
On June 10, the day before the primary, Lee sued. The lawsuit named Flippo, his campaign and political blogger Lou Colagiovanni.
The suit alleged Colagiovanni offered the audio to Flippo’s campaign for $20,000. It didn’t say whether that sale ever happened.
McShane’s firm was running Flippo’s campaign at the time. He issued his usual flat denial:
“The Flippo campaign was not involved in the publication of this website or recording in anyway, and went as far as to preemptively make the Lee campaign aware of its existence more than six months ago.”
I couldn’t find how the lawsuit was resolved, but let’s be clear.
I’m not saying Flippo was behind that website. I’m saying a fellow Republican accused him of it in court, the day before Republican voters went to the polls.
Meanwhile, a super PAC called American Honor PAC spent $130,591 attacking Lee in the final two weeks. Billboards. Mail. Digital ads. Video. Texts.
Flippo lost to Lee by about three points.
Keeping It in the Family
That super PAC deserves a closer look. It shows up in both of Flippo’s congressional primaries.
FEC records show American Honor PAC registered on Dec. 26, 2022.
That’s the same day Flippo’s first congressional campaign committee filed its statement of organization. Their FEC ID numbers are nearly consecutive.
The PAC reported $200,000 in contributions by the end of 2022. Then it sat on the money for about 17 months.
In the last two weeks of the 2024 primary, it spent $130,591 attacking John Lee.
In 2026, it was back.
On May 19, it reported a $91,827 media buy and $13,173 in text messaging supporting Flippo.
One of its vendors, Tactical Campaigns LLC, also handled its attacks on Lee in 2024.
Who Paid for It?
Sheehan reported in May that the PAC’s only donor is Stephen Flippo. That’s apparently the candidate’s brother.
She also reported that the PAC and Flippo’s 2026 campaign share the same treasurer, Thomas Datwyler.
And she found the PAC used footage from Flippo’s own campaign YouTube channel in an ad.
The PAC doesn’t hide where its heart is. Its website says its “first and foremost priority is to support the campaign of distinguished Lt. Col. David Flippo.”
Super PACs aren’t allowed to coordinate with campaigns. And I’m not saying this one did.
But a PAC born the same day as the campaign, funded by the candidate’s brother, sharing the candidate’s treasurer and using the candidate’s own video?
I’m sure that’s just another coincidence, right?
The Common Thread
Three primaries. Three Republican opponents.
Each time, damaging material surfaced through a third party. An anonymous website. An obscure blog. A small partisan news site.
And each time, Team Flippo’s fingerprints were… not quite there. Just close by.
The common thread is Rory McShane.
McShane’s firm ran Flippo’s 2024 campaign. It’s running his 2026 campaign.
As of June, Flippo’s campaign had reportedly paid RMC nearly $1.5 million.
Johnston is McShane’s former vice president. And this isn’t their first controversy.
The Proud Boys Message
On election night 2020, McShane’s firm was working for the Nevada GOP.
That night, Johnston sent a Facebook message to a political operative.
“We might need to do the same here in Nevada,” Johnston wrote, referring to a protest push in Arizona. “Which means we need to get the Proud Boys out.”
When The Washington Post reported it, McShane said:
“I was unaware of these texts, but I know Mr. Johnston was not working on behalf of any client or organization.”
He added: “Our management team has met with Mr. Johnston. I’m confident he sees the error of what he did.”
Johnston kept his job.
In 2023, Nashville mayoral candidate Alice Rolli fired McShane’s firm. She said she learned it had “more than a strong connection to Proud Boys.”
She’d already spent two-thirds of her campaign money with the firm.
McShane doesn’t seem bothered by any of this.
In fact, he seems to revel in it. All while crying over spilt milk when Republican voters choose not to reward his mud-slinging tactics.
Questions That Deserve Answers
We don’t have every answer. But these questions deserve them.
To Woody Johnston: Did you know Joe Michael was recording Cody Whipple? Did you approve it? Did anyone on the Flippo campaign know?
To Joe Michael: Who asked you to record that conversation? Who got the recording first?
To Rob Lauer: Who gave 360 News the Whipple video? Has 360 News or anyone connected to it been paid by the Flippo campaign, RMC or American Honor PAC?
To Rory McShane: Did you have Settelmeyer’s sealed court records before they were published? If so, where did you get them?
To Stephen Flippo: Why did you fund a super PAC on the same day your brother launched his first congressional campaign?
To David Flippo: Did you know about any of this? And do you think the Republicans you ran against were treated fairly?
Loyalty Is a Two-Way Street
Look, this race matters.
CD2 has never elected a Democrat. Plenty of good Republicans will hold their noses to block out the stench and vote for Flippo anyway.
That’s their call. It’s a legitimate one. I understand their position.
But Republicans like Bob Seale and Mark Amodei have made a different call. You can disagree with them, but that doesn’t make them party traitors.
They’ve watched Flippo’s team smear John Lee, Cody Whipple and James Settelmeyer. Fellow Republicans, all three.
And now the same crew wants to lecture Republicans about loyalty? GTFOH.
Loyalty isn’t something you demand after the primary. It’s something you have to earn. And with many CD2 voters, Flippo-McShane hasn’t earned it.
In McShane’s own words, they decided to “sling all [the] mud you want.” So they don’t get to be surprised when some Republicans decide to take a water cannon filled with industrial-strength disinfectant to the whole thing.
The opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Nevada News & Views. Digital technology may have been used in the research, writing, or production of this article. Please verify information and consult additional sources as needed.