OPINION: I Nearly Died During a Miscarriage — That’s Why I Read the Fine Print on Question 6

Posted By


 

Nevada’s abortion law has required physicians, and hospitals for later procedures since 1990. Question 6 does not. 

I almost died from a miscarriage.

I was about nine weeks pregnant when I began hemorrhaging. I lost so much blood that I could no longer stand or walk.

I needed to get to the hospital, but I couldn’t get to the car. At one point, I considered putting a blanket on the tile floor so another woman, who couldn’t carry me, could drag me across it.

Then, inexplicably, I found enough strength to stand and make it to the car.

I brought my own sheet to the hospital because I was bleeding so heavily, I needed something to sit on.

Walking from the triage chair to a hospital bed, I began to lose my vision. Black spots filled my sight, and I felt myself slipping toward unconsciousness.

Then came a violent, painful shaking I couldn’t control. I believe it was shock from the blood loss. What I remember most is how painful the muscles contracting in my extremities were and how little control I had over my own body.

I needed an emergency dilation and curettage, commonly known as a D&C.

The emergency department didn’t have the instruments on hand. They had to bring them down from labor and delivery. And I was fortunate: there happened to be a doctor in the emergency room who knew how to perform the procedure.

My blood loss was severe enough that a transfusion was on the table. After talking it through with my doctor, I declined.

I’ve thought many times about how many things had to go right to survive. There had to be a hospital. There had to be the right equipment. And there had to be a physician capable of performing the procedure I needed.

Remove any one of those things, and I believe I would be dead.

What My Story Is, and What It Isn’t

Question 6 would not have changed the care I received that night. This event occurred in California, but Nevada has never restricted miscarriage treatment, and that matters.

I was raised in a Catholic family, and that upbringing has shaped my own decisions about pregnancy. But nearly dying taught me something personal conviction alone couldn’t: pregnancy is medically complicated, and the laws governing it have to account for situations that don’t fit neatly into political arguments.

That cuts both ways. I understand why abortion laws can’t be so rigid that a physician hesitates to perform a lifesaving procedure, or that a woman who miscarries finds herself under suspicion. Women in other states have faced exactly that, and access to timely care is a real concern.

I also know that medical qualifications, hospital resources, and professional standards matter, because they are what kept me alive.

Those aren’t contradictory concerns.

Nevada voters weighed both in 1990, when they retained a statutory framework permitting abortion through 24 weeks, with exceptions afterward for the life or health of the pregnant woman, alongside requirements governing physicians and hospital care.

That framework has governed Nevada for decades. It reflects both the access voters chose to preserve and the medical requirements written into state law.

My concern is how a new constitutional standard would interact with the requirements voters attached to that access.

What Nevada Law Requires Today

Under NRS 442.250, Nevada law currently requires:

  • Abortions must be performed by a licensed physician.
  • Abortion is permitted through 24 weeks. After that, it is permitted when a physician reasonably believes it is necessary to preserve the life or health of the pregnant woman.
  • Abortions after 24 weeks, or when there is a reasonable likelihood the fetus could survive outside the womb, must take place in a licensed hospital.
  • The physician must document the medical circumstances justifying a later procedure.

The hospital and documentation requirements apply most heavily later in pregnancy, when medical complications are most serious.

What Question 6 Would Change

Question 6 would establish a fundamental constitutional right to abortion until fetal viability, and afterward when needed to protect the life or health of the pregnant patient. The state could not “interfere” with that right unless it proves a compelling interest pursued by the least restrictive means.

But the proposed constitutional language differs from existing Nevada law in three important respects.

First, it replaces the fixed 24-week threshold with a viability standard defined case-by-case.

Under Question 6, viability is the point at which, in the professional judgment of the patient’s treating practitioner, there is a significant likelihood of sustained survival outside the uterus without extraordinary medical measures.

That is not a fixed line. It depends on the individual pregnancy and on an individual practitioner’s judgment.

Second, it does not preserve the physician requirement.

It uses the broader phrase “qualified health care practitioner.”

Supporters will say “qualified” is a meaningful limit. But qualified by whom, and under what standard? Any definition the Legislature writes would have to survive a “least restrictive means” test, so that question would ultimately be decided in court.

Third, it does not preserve the licensed-hospital requirement for abortions after 24 weeks.

The amendment would not automatically repeal existing medical regulations.

Every law that burdens the new right would have to meet the amendment’s demanding standard. That creates real uncertainty about whether Nevada’s physician and hospital requirements would remain enforceable.

Michigan Shows How This Plays Out

Nevada wouldn’t be the first state to face these questions.

After Michigan voters adopted a constitutional amendment protecting abortion rights in 2022, abortion providers sued over the state’s remaining regulations. In May 2025, the Michigan Court of Claims ruled in Northland Family Planning Center v. Nessel that several of them violated the amendment.

The ruling is now on appeal.

Among the provisions struck down was Michigan’s rule that only physicians could perform abortions, which excluded nurse practitioners, certified nurse midwives, and physician assistants. The court also invalidated Michigan’s 24-hour waiting period and its uniform informed-consent requirements.

That rule was narrow. It applied to trained, licensed clinicians, and it still didn’t survive. Nevada’s physician requirement would face the same kind of test.

Our hospital requirement would face its own. A court would weigh it separately, but it would have no special protection simply because the amendment doesn’t mention it.

The lesson from Michigan is that existing safeguards are not preserved just because an amendment doesn’t expressly repeal them.

Access and Safety Shouldn’t Be Competing Priorities

The question is whether Nevada’s existing statutory safeguards would remain legally enforceable under the constitutional standard Question 6 proposes.

How would the new viability definition interact with the statutory 24-week threshold?

Would the state still be able to require a licensed hospital for abortions after 24 weeks?

Would the existing requirement for a physician survive?

If those requirements were challenged, what evidence would the state need to demonstrate that those requirements satisfy the new constitutional standard?

Those are questions about the practical consequences of changing Nevada’s constitution. They deserve substantive answers.

The reality is that if Question 6 passes, judges, not voters, will have the final word on those answers.

I Survived Because the Right Care Was There

My experience can’t tell us how a Nevada court would interpret every word of Question 6.

But it explains why I take the gap between our current law and the proposed amendment seriously. I know what it means to need immediate medical intervention. I know how much depends on the resources and expertise in the room at that moment.

A “no” vote on Question 6 doesn’t take anything away from Nevada women.

It keeps the law voters approved in 1990, a law no legislator can change without going back to the people. Under that law, a licensed physician performs every abortion in this state, and a licensed hospital is required when pregnancies are furthest along, and complications are most dangerous.

A “yes” vote replaces those certainties with a constitutional standard that courts will interpret one challenge at a time.

At nine weeks pregnant, I needed a hospital, a doctor, and a surgical procedure to survive. A woman further along in pregnancy, facing an emergency, deserves no less. That is why I urge you to vote no on Question 6.

The views expressed in this opinion piece are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Nevada News & Views or Citizen Outreach Foundation. This article was written with the assistance of AI.