• About Us
  • Activity
  • Advertising
  • Books
  • Business
  • Contact
  • Dashboard
  • EB5
  • Entertainment
  • feedback
  • Forgot Your Password?
  • Government
  • Home
  • Home 20723
  • Interviews
  • Login
  • Members
  • Meme generator
  • National
  • Nevada
  • Nevada News and Views
  • Newsmax
  • NN&V Ads
  • Opinion
  • Pick a New Password
  • Politics
  • Polls
  • Privacy Policy
  • Profile
  • Recent comments by me
  • Recent comments on my posts
  • Register
  • Submit post
  • Subscribe
  • Subscription Confirmation
  • Survey
  • Survey
  • Terms of Service
  • Today’s Top 10
  • Travel
  • Travel
  • Travel
  • Welcome!
  • Yop Poll Archive
Nevada News and Views
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • More
    • Opinion
  • Facebook

  • Twitter

  • Pinterest

  • RSS

Opinion

Markets work, even for those in poverty, UNR professors have it wrong

Markets work, even for those in poverty, UNR professors have it wrong
Chuck Muth
March 30, 2010

(Patrick R. Gibbons/Nevada Policy Research Institute) – Contrary to popular opinion, Nevada public education has not been devastated by budget cuts. K-12 schools still received more money this biennium than the last, while higher education has as much money today as in the booming 2005-07 biennium.

Instead of focusing on how much we spend, we should focus on spending resources more effectively by adopting market-oriented reforms. Of course, progressives are still concerned that markets don’t work to help those in need.

Elliott Parker and Maureen Kilkenny, two economics professors at the University of Nevada, Reno, recently stated that “markets can do nothing for people with nothing.” To these two, poverty excludes people from participating and succeeding in the free market. This is why, they argue, we need taxation to pay for government services like public education.

The poorest nations in Africa and Asia are the perfect places to test their theory. If the Parker-Kilkenny thesis is true, we should observe markets failing the world’s poorest people. Fortunately for the poor, the UNR profs are dead wrong — free markets do a great job helping the poor better themselves.

Dr. James Tooley is the author of The Beautiful Tree: A Personal Journey Into How the World’s Poorest People are Educating Themselves. A professor at the University of Newcastle in England, Dr. Tooley visited some of the world’s poorest countries and made a discovery that stunned him: The world’s poorest people are setting up their own private schools, some charging tuitions as low as $1 a week. Not only are the world’s poorest parents sending their kids to private schools, but, Dr. Tooley discovered, these private schools regularly outperform the better-funded, “free” public schools.

Tooley discovered the same phenomenon among the poor of the world’s largest democracy, India. Even within that long-standing democracy — with its enduring focus on social justice — government public schools fail to provide quality education to the poor. Yet, private schools for the poor succeed.

In Nevada, as in the Third World, government schools are failing. Only 42 percent of the state’s low-income fourth-grade students can read at grade level, according to the National Assessment of Educational Progress. The story is similar all across the U.S. Lacking the real-world incentives that naturally arise in private-sector markets, central bureaucracies ration public-school resources from above and micromanage schools and teachers. Because parents have no say in where and how and by whom their child will be educated, the school systems remain unaccountable.

Public schools — wherever they exist — underperform when insulated from the concerns of parents. Yet public education can improve if we stop defending the status quo and embrace market-oriented reforms that empower parents.

Vouchers, tax credits, charter schools, virtual schools, open enrollment and empowerment schools (school decentralization) can all have a major impact on the quality of education.

We merely need the political will to change.

(Mr. Gibbons is an education policy analyst at the Nevada Policy Research Institute. For more visit http://npri.org)

Prev postNext post

Related Items
Opinion
March 30, 2010
Chuck Muth

Related Items

More in Opinion

Amodei Statement on Debt Ceiling Bill

Chuck MuthJune 1, 2023
Read More

Tark: Trans “Rights” … and Wrongs

Chuck MuthMay 26, 2023
Read More

Stone: The Truth About AB 250: Will Patients Really Benefit?

NN&V StaffMay 26, 2023
Read More

“Ungrateful Miscreants”: Miller, Segerblom Insult Local Small Business Owners

NN&V StaffMay 24, 2023
Read More

Quarter-Million Dollar Ad Campaign Targets Nevada Legislators for Trapping Hispanic Families in Unsafe Schools

NN&V StaffMay 22, 2023
Read More

Nevada News & Views: May 20, 2023

NN&V StaffMay 20, 2023
Read More
Scroll for more
Tap

Subscribe Free By Email

Looking for the best in breaking news and conservative views? Let Chuck do all the work for you! Subscribe to his FREE "Muth's Truths" e-newsletter.

* indicates required
Nevada News and Views
Nevada News & Views is an educational project of Citizen Outreach Foundation, a non-partisan IRS-approved 501(c)(3) organization. It is not associated or affiliated with any political party or group. Nevada News & Views is accessible by the public at no cost. It funds its operations through tax-deductible contributions from donors and supporters and does not accept government money or grants.

TAGS

Featured Article Muths truth

Copyright © 2023 Citizen Outreach | Maintained by VirtualAlly

Tea Party After-Action Report
Enough is Enough, Time to Fire Berkley