You’d think “don’t torture dogs” would be a pretty low bar for working at an animal shelter.
Apparently not.
Federal officials say a Las Vegas animal shelter worker accused of abusing dogs was also in the country illegally after overstaying his visa by four years.
A DHS release today highlights “an illegal alien facing felony charges for animal torture” who was arrested by LVMPD and is in ICE custody.
Fits Trump campaign messaging focusing on deporting criminals—and not the crackdown that’s cost voter support.https://t.co/Gd9CPdI5B7
— Mini Racker (@MiniRacker) May 4, 2026
According to the Department of Homeland Security, 31-year-old John Young Cotter Johnstone, a citizen of the United Kingdom, was arrested April 1 by Las Vegas Metro Police after a month-long animal cruelty investigation.
And the allegations are ugly.
Police say videos showed Johnstone repeatedly shocking dogs with electronic collars, forcing their heads to the ground with leashes, and even swinging dogs in the air by those leashes.
At an animal shelter. The place that’s supposed to protect them.
Johnstone now faces four felony charges related to torturing and mutilating animals.
Then out came the immigration issue.
DHS says Johnstone entered the United States legally in 2021 through the Visa Waiver Program. He was supposed to leave by February 2022. He didn’t.
ICE issued a detainer the same day he was arrested. Clark County officials honored it the next day and transferred him into federal custody.
Which, believe it or not, has become controversial in modern American politics.
Acting Assistant DHS Secretary Lauren Bis praised Clark County for cooperating with ICE.
“This disgusting criminal tortured dogs at the shelter where he worked,” Bis said in a statement Monday. “Thanks to the cooperation of Clark County officials who honored the ICE detainer, this freak is in ICE custody.”
She also pointed out something immigration hardliners have known for years: local cooperation matters.
“Seven of the ten safest cities cooperate with ICE,” Bis added. “We need more state and local politicians to work with us to keep criminals off our streets and out of our country.”
Critics of ICE detainers argue local police shouldn’t act as immigration agents. They worry that aggressive immigration enforcement can make some immigrant communities less willing to report crimes or cooperate with law enforcement.
That’s the political argument. The public reaction is usually a little less complicated.
Especially when the suspect is accused of torturing dogs while illegally overstaying a visa by four years.
At that point, most voters aren’t asking for a policy white paper. They’re asking why the system failed in the first place, and how soon we can kick the guy back out.
The case also brings up something politicians rarely do when discussing illegal immigration: visa overstays.
Not everyone enters illegally by crossing the southern border. Millions come legally through visas and simply decide the expiration date is more of a guideline than an actual rule.
And yes, before somebody says it, overstaying a visa from the U.K. doesn’t fit the media’s usual image of illegal immigration.
Funny how the law still applies anyway.
For conservatives, this case checks every box of what frustrates voters about immigration enforcement in the first place.
- A broken system.
- Weak enforcement.
- And politicians who often seem more worried about offending activists than protecting the public.
Or apparently, protecting dogs.
Meanwhile, Johnstone remains in custody while the criminal case moves through Nevada’s court system and ICE handles the immigration side.
If someone accused of torturing animals can overstay a visa for four years without consequences until after felony charges show up, that doesn’t exactly sound like a working system.
The opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Nevada News & Views. Digital technology was used in the research, writing, and production of this article. Please verify information and consult additional sources as needed.
