• About Us
  • Activity
  • Advertising
  • Books
  • Business
  • Contact
  • EB5
  • Entertainment
  • feedback
  • Government
  • Home
  • Interviews
  • Members
  • National
  • Nevada
  • Nevada News and Views
  • Newsmax
  • NN&V Ads
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Polls
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe
  • Subscription Confirmation
  • Survey
  • Survey
  • Terms of Service
  • Today’s Top 10
  • Travel
  • Travel
  • Travel
  • Welcome!
  • Yop Poll Archive
Nevada News and Views
  • Home
  • Muth’s Truths
  • Politics
  • Government
  • Entertainment
  • More
    • Nevada
    • Opinion
    • Business
    • Travel
    • News
    • Sports
  • Facebook

  • Twitter

  • Pinterest

  • RSS

Nevada

Knecht & Lawrence: Repealing The Commerce Tax Will Not Unbalance the Budget

Knecht & Lawrence: Repealing The Commerce Tax Will Not Unbalance the Budget
N&V Staff
April 27, 2016

Ron Knecht(Ron Knecht & Geoffrey Lawrence) – Recently, Ron spoke to an industry group about the petition to give voters the final say this fall on the onerous Commerce Tax passed by the Legislature and Governor last year.

A lawyer for referendum opponents also spoke, and we were appalled at their attitude toward Nevada voters and the grossly false arguments they make against a referendum.

The lawyer quoted Sir Winston Churchill: “The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter.”  Churchill said that, all right, but his point is open to interpretation.  In the same vein, people have noted that democracy is a poor form of government until you consider all the alternatives.

But the lawyer was not being philosophical.  He made absolutely clear that his side thoroughly despises Nevada voters and believes you are not fit to decide serious matters of tax and budget policy, despite the fact that the state constitution guarantees the people exactly that right.

According to them, we little people lack the intelligence, high-mindedness, magnanimous vision, compassion, benevolence, nobility and even savoir-faire that our tax-and-spend betters in the Legislature and Governor’s office possess.  So, we simply have no business voting on such important matters.

Maybe that’s because we crass voters shot down a very similar measure, the Margins Tax, in the 2014 election by nearly a 4-to-1 vote.  The large harem of Establishment politicians supported by entrenched special interests, who have long sought to impose a gross receipts tax on non-gaming Nevada businesses, think we all are just too ignorant and insensitive.  So, we should just butt out.

But if that arrogant viewpoint is not enough to win the day, they add many ridiculous and dishonest claims about what repealing the Commerce Tax will do.  Most notable among these arguments is the completely false allegation that it would blow a hole in the state budget.  Related false claims include that repeal would devastate K-12 education, cause the return of furloughs for state employees or require a special legislative session. Oh, the humanity!!!

None of it is true.

In fact, the alternative budget we presented to the Legislature would have significantly increased education spending from prior levels – levels that have risen greatly in real terms over the last decade as the incomes of Nevada families and businesses have declined significantly.  The method we proposed is similar to one used by Governor Scott Walker to balance Wisconsin’s budget without tax hikes.

Some Establishment politicians are now falsely saying our budget was “unconstitutional.”  Since our budget was accompanied by a letter from the Legislature’s chief legal counsel, who found no problems with it, this is a lie.  A lie they didn’t have the gall to raise in the hearings on our proposed budget, where we could have rebutted it on the record.

But back to the alleged budget hole, special sessions, and draconian cuts.  The Commerce Tax was designed to start small so it could be ramped up in future legislative sessions.  Now, it accounts for only 1.2 percent of state general-fund outlays and 0.5 percent of total state spending.  Lawmakers and budgeteers deal with much larger variances than this from adopted revenue estimates regularly, as do taxpayers in their budgets.  Our referendum would not touch the larger tax hikes on payroll and licensing fees passed last year, just the Commerce Tax.

This year, Nevada businesses and some individuals will have to file Commerce Tax returns between July 1 and August 15.  Monies due will be collected regardless of the referendum’s fate in November – just as projected in the budget process.

However, if the Commerce Tax is repealed in November, it will reduce expected net revenues by $60 million for the biennium.  But that revenue would not have been collected until August 2017, anyway, and in the meantime the Legislature will meet early in 2017 to adopt a new budget, taking all that into account.

We and the Legislators, lawyers and business and professional people, who crafted this referendum, put careful thought into its details and implications. When the trial court heard the tax-and-spend claims in December, it rejected all of them definitively.  So don’t be fooled by the desperate lies our opponents are peddling, nor their contempt for the voters.

 

Ron Knecht is Nevada State Controller.  Geoffrey Lawrence is Assistant Controller.

Prev postNext post

Related ItemsCommerce TaxGov. Brian SandovalMargins TaxTax
Nevada
April 27, 2016
N&V Staff

Related ItemsCommerce TaxGov. Brian SandovalMargins TaxTax

More in Nevada

Election Integrity in Washoe County

N&V StaffAugust 1, 2022
Read More

The Race for Governor is Heating Up!

N&V StaffJuly 25, 2022
Read More

McMahill Announces Major Police Endorsements

N&V StaffApril 6, 2022
Read More

Rosen, Masto Should Oppose Sohn Nomination to FCC

N&V StaffMarch 23, 2022
Read More

Game On! Chattah Files for Attorney General, Blasts Ford and Black

N&V StaffMarch 17, 2022
Read More

Lexit Nevada President Endorses Nevada Governor Candidate Joey Gilbert

N&V StaffMarch 4, 2022
Read More
Scroll for more
Tap

Subscribe Free By Email

Looking for the best in breaking news and conservative views? Let Chuck do all the work for you! Subscribe to his FREE "Muth's Truths" e-newsletter.

* indicates required
Nevada News and Views
Nevada News & Views is an educational project of Citizen Outreach Foundation, a non-partisan IRS-approved 501(c)(3) organization. It is not associated or affiliated with any political party or group. Nevada News & Views is accessible by the public at no cost. It funds its operations through tax-deductible contributions from donors and supporters and does not accept government money or grants.

TAGS

Featured Article Nevada Politics business Muth's Truths government Government Opinion Muth’s Truths Obama Ron Knecht News Donald Trump GOP Republicans

Copyright © 2022 Citizen Outreach | Maintained by VirtualAlly

Nevada AG’s Office Urges Judge To Rule Soon On Case Involving School Choice Bill
Weinberg: Nevada Taxpayers Association… Lying About Who They Represent Statewide