The Consultant Merry-Go-Round That Keeps Losing Elections

Posted By



 

Same Consultants. Same Playbook. Same Results.

In professional sports, if a coach loses season after season, he gets fired.

In politics, he gets another contract.

That’s one of the strangest things about how campaigns are run in this country. The same consultants keep getting hired, cycle after cycle, no matter how many races they lose.

And conservative leaders have been sounding the alarm about it for years.

Viguerie saw it coming

Richard Viguerie, the godfather of conservative direct mail, has been one of the loudest critics.

The day after Mitt Romney lost in 2012, Viguerie held a press conference at the National Press Club. He named names.

Big-name establishment consultants like Karl Rove and Romney strategist Stuart Stevens, he said, should never be hired to run or consult on a national campaign again.

(For some reason, a certain consultant on a certain congressional campaign in Nevada this cycle immediately comes to mind in this regard.)

Two years later, he devoted a section of his book “Takeover” to the issue. Its title said it all: “Consultants make millions wrecking the GOP”.

He wasn’t alone.

At the 2013 Conservative Political Action Conference, there was actually a panel titled “Should we shoot all the consultants now?”

Newt Gingrich piled on too. He wrote that it was “appalling how little some Republican consultants have learned from the 2012 defeat.”

More than a decade later, the complaints haven’t stopped.

After the GOP’s disappointing 2022 midterms, former Kansas Congressman Tim Huelskamp put it bluntly:

“Big money campaign consultants on the GOP side are in the business of losing.”

It’s not just a Republican problem

To be fair, Democrats have the same disease.

Back in 2005, the left-leaning Washington Monthly ran a piece called “Fire the Consultants.”

It described a clique of Washington consultants who, through their insider ties, continue to get rewarded with business even after losing continually.

The magazine pointed to Democratic strategist Bob Shrum, who worked on the campaigns of seven losing presidential candidates over his career. He kept getting hired anyway.

So this isn’t about one party. It’s about an industry that doesn’t hold itself accountable.

The cookie-cutter playbook

One of the biggest complaints is that too many consultants run every campaign the same way.

Raise a pile of money. Spend most of it on TV. Send a few glossy mailers in the final weeks. Repeat.

It doesn’t matter if it’s a congressional race in Ohio or a legislative race in Nevada. Same playbook. Same vendors. Same results.

Why? Follow the money.

Paid to spend, not paid to win

Many media consultants are paid a commission on the ads they buy. The industry standard has long been around 15 percent.

So the more TV a campaign buys, the more the consultant makes.

A study by the Center for Public Integrity found that veteran consultants and experts say the commission structure creates a conflict of interest because there’s an incentive to recommend sizable television campaigns.

And here’s the kicker. Commentator Erick Erickson pointed out that they get paid commissions whether a candidate wins or loses.

Think about that. A consultant can lose your race and still walk away with a fat check.

It gets worse for Republicans.

Researchers at Stanford University studied TV ad spending across three election cycles.

They found that “Republican media consultants appear to be working less hard on their clients’ behalf to negotiate the best prices for media time.”

In other words, GOP candidates are paying a premium.

The insider pipeline

So why do the same consultants keep getting hired?

Insiders.

In both parties, candidates get steered by party committees, caucus leaders, and big donors toward a short list of “approved” consultants and vendors.

Often, those consultants are former staffers or friends of the people doing the steering.

The Federalist described it as a revolving door between congressional staff, GOP leadership PACs, and media consultants.

New candidates don’t know any better. They’re told who to hire, and they hire them. Then they lose. And the same consultants get handed the next batch of candidates.

That’s not a free market. That’s a closed shop.

Cherry-picking the easy races

There’s another problem that doesn’t get talked about enough. Many consultants pick their clients very carefully.

They want candidates who can write their own checks. Or candidates who already have big donor networks. Or candidates running in safe districts where the party registration does most of the work.

Why? Because it pads their win-loss record.

A consultant who only takes slam-dunk races can brag about winning 90 percent of the time. But what did they actually do? Their candidates would’ve won anyway.

One article in Campaigns & Elections, the industry’s own trade magazine, made the point plainly.

A consultant’s win-loss record partially reflects the quality and skill of the consultant, but to an even larger degree it reflects the quality of the consultant’s clients.

Academic research backs this up.

A Stanford study found that the highest-quality consultants are not allocated to the most competitive races. And consulting firms that work for challengers face a higher risk of going out of business.

Another analysis put it simply: there is no incentive for the best consultants to work on the toughest, most competitive races.

So the best talent flocks to the safest races. And the tough races, the ones that actually decide which party controls a legislature or Congress, get whoever’s left.

That’s backwards.

What a good consultant should do

Here’s how consultants should be judged. Not by how many races they won. By how much better their candidates did than expected.

Did a candidate in a district where their party was down 10 points lose by just two? That’s a consultant who earned their pay. Even though the candidate lost.

Did a candidate in a district where their party was up 15 points win by 12? That consultant underperformed. Even though the candidate won.

That’s the kind of scorecard that matters.

What both parties need are consultants and campaign managers willing to take on tough races.

People who can take a long-shot race and make it competitive. People who build something, instead of just cashing in on a sure thing.

Those are the races that build majorities. And they’re the races that build future candidates, too.

Time for an overhaul

So what needs to change? A few things.

Candidates should shop around. Don’t just hire whoever the party or caucus tells you to hire. Interview several consultants. Ask hard questions.

Ask for real results. Not just a win-loss record.

Ask how their candidates did compared to the district’s partisan lean. Ask about the tough races they took on, not just the easy ones they won.

Pay for performance, not for spending.

Many experts now recommend paying consultants a flat fee or monthly retainer instead of a commission. As one Campaigns & Elections article put it, “They should not spend money to make money.”

Party committees and caucuses should stop steering candidates to a favored few. Open the process. Let new talent compete.

And donors should start asking questions.

Before you write a big check, ask who the consultants are. Ask what they’ve done. Ask how much of your money will go to commissions.

The bottom line

Politics may be the only business where you can fail over and over and still get promoted.

That has to stop.

Losing consultants shouldn’t keep getting hired just because they know the right people. And consultants shouldn’t be rewarded for only picking races they can’t lose.

The consultants worth hiring are the ones willing to take on a tough race and make it a real fight.

Those are the people who win majorities.

The opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Nevada News & Views. Digital technology may have been used in the research, writing, or production of this article. Please verify information and consult additional sources as needed.